Book Review: In Every Generation by Kendare Blake
As a lifelong fan of Buffy the Vampire Slayer, I approached In Every Generation, the first book in the new series by Kendare Blake, with a thrilled heart and a tinge of trepidation. Like many, I’ve passionately debated the merits of the original show and its myriad spin-offs—an intricate universe that shaped my formative years. So, did this latest entry into the Buffyverse deliver the nostalgia I craved, or did it stumble in its quest to capture that iconic magic?
Diving into the narrative, it’s evident Blake aims to capture the essence of those early seasons—the biting humor, the camaraderie amongst the Scoobies, and the unmistakable blend of supernatural intrigue with teenage angst. The writing breathes with a voice reminiscent of classic Buffy, embracing its quirky charm. The dialogue crackles, blending modern sensibilities with the show’s original spunk, which was immediately comforting and invigorating for this seasoned fan. For those who long for the early magic, this book feels like a homecoming.
One of the most delightful elements was the introduction of the new Scoobies. Among them, Jake, the adorable werewolf boy with a heart of gold, easily stole my heart. The camaraderie among the new characters, interwoven with ties to the originals, felt both fresh and fun. The friendships sparkled with chemistry, echoing the classic dynamics we loved.
And let’s not forget the nostalgia factor! For die-hard fans, the plethora of Buffy references is a treasure trove. Whether overt or subtly integrated into the story, these callbacks invoke that warm, familiar feeling of the series. It’s like a sprinkling of “remember when?” that feels inclusive rather than indulgent.
However, it isn’t without its pitfalls. The portrayal of Willow’s sexuality left me feeling uneasy. The plot’s reliance on a non-consensual pregnancy storyline is problematic, especially for a character who has historically epitomized queer representation. Disregarding Willow’s identity in favor of a will-they-won’t-they with Oz felt disheartening. It risks erasing years of character development and the cultural significance she holds as a lesbian icon.
Frankie, the new Slayers’ character, while interesting on paper, felt more like an afterthought than a fully fleshed protagonist. Her arc lacked the depth I longed for, often leaving me wishing for more character growth or more substantial interactions with the old guard.
Towards the end, In Every Generation raises more questions than it answers, leaving lingering doubts about the fates of beloved characters like Faith and Buffy. It feels like a strategy to keep readers on their toes, but I found my patience wearing thin as unresolved plotlines piled up.
Despite these imperfections, the overall experience of revisiting this universe felt rewarding. I believe this book will resonate with new readers, especially those who may appreciate it independently of its lineage. For devoted fans like me, it’s a mixed bag—delightful in parts, yet frustratingly flawed in others.
If you’re searching for a nostalgic romp through Sunnydale, filled with charming new characters and familiar vibes, then grab this book. Just be prepared for moments that may leave you questioning rather than celebrating. In Every Generation may have left me wanting more, but it also reminded me of the magic that first ignited my love for this universe. A solid 3 out of 5 stars—an enjoyable, if imperfect, journey back to the Slayer world.
Discover more about In Every Generation (In Every Generation, #1) on GoodReads >>